Movie Review: "The Chosen"

"The Chosen" is a film adaptation of Chaim Potok's 1967 novel. It tells the story of two boys from different Jewish backgrounds who learn to understand and respect each other's traditions. Set against the backdrop of World War II and the creation of Israel, this movie explores themes of friendship, faith, and cultural differences.

Plot Summary

The story begins on a playground where Reuven, the son of a progressive Jewish intellectual, accidentally injures Danny, the son of a strict Hasidic rabbi, during a baseball game. This incident leads Reuven to visit Danny at his home, introducing him to a world of ancient traditions and strict discipline.

Reuven's father, played by Maximilian Schell, is a Zionist involved in the establishment of a Jewish state. In contrast, Danny's father, portrayed by Rod Steiger, wants his son to avoid politics and remain immersed in their religious traditions. Despite these differences, Reuven (Barry Miller) and Danny (Robby Benson) develop a deep friendship.

Characters and Performances

The film features strong performances from its cast. Barry Miller and Robby Benson bring their characters to life, showing the struggles and growth of two boys from vastly different worlds. Maximilian Schell and Rod Steiger deliver powerful performances as their fathers, representing the conflicting ideologies of the time.

Themes and Execution

"The Chosen" explores the tension between tradition and modernity, as well as the importance of understanding and respecting different beliefs. The film's period production is impressive, capturing the look and feel of the era with fedoras, brown overcoats, and classic cars.

However, the movie falls short in terms of spontaneity and surprise. The plot feels predictable, and the characters’ actions are often locked into the storyline without much room for unexpected developments. This makes the crises and resolutions seem inevitable and somewhat unengaging.

Critique

While "The Chosen" aims to showcase the power of mutual respect and understanding, it sometimes oversimplifies the complexity of personal beliefs. The film suggests that different backgrounds can easily be reconciled, but in reality, deeply held beliefs are not so easily set aside. This lack of depth in addressing the importance of individual convictions may leave some viewers unsatisfied.

Conclusion

"The Chosen" is a well-intentioned film with strong performances and impressive production design. It tells an important story about friendship and cultural understanding, but its predictable plot and simplified message may not resonate deeply with everyone. Despite its flaws, it remains a meaningful exploration of two boys navigating the challenges of their differing worlds.

Availability

"The Chosen" has had a complicated journey to distribution but is worth watching for its heartfelt exploration of friendship and faith. If you enjoy films about cultural differences and the importance of understanding, this movie might be for you.